Monkeys, Typewriters, and Shakespeare
June 21, 2007
The driver behind evolutionary change, we are told, is mutation. Genes foul up in replicating, the theory goes, and the result is a slight tweak on life. Add up enough tweaks, millions upon millions, and look! an amoeba has become an orangutan.
Most mutations, though, are bad news. And so, natural selection emerges as the determinant of which ones die out and which ones are preserved, to be passed on to the next generation. Only a beneficial mutation is preserved, since only that variety gives one an advantage in the "fight for survival."
Gene replication is amazingly accurate. "Typically, mistakes are made at a rate of only 1 in every ten billion bases incorporated," states the textbook Microbiology. (Tortora, Funke, Case, 2004, pg 217) That's not many, and, remember, only the tiniest fraction of those mutations are said to be any good.
Since gene mutations rarely happen, and almost all that do are neutral or negative, and thus not enshrined by natural selection, a student might reasonably wonder if he is not being sold a bill of goods by evolutionists. Can benevolent mutations possibly account for all they are said to account for?
Enter Thomas Huxley, a 19th-century scientist who supported Charles Darwin's theories of evolution. Huxley came up with the pithy slogan: "If you give an infinite number of monkeys and infinite number of typewriters, one of them will eventually come up with the complete works of Shakespeare." Surely you can understand that!
Nevertheless, his assertion had never been tested. Until 4 years ago, that is. Evolutionists at England's Plymouth University rounded up six monkeys, supplied them with a computer, placed them on display at Paighton Zoo, and then hid behind trees and trash cans, with notebooks, breathlessly awaiting what would happen! They were disappointed.Four weeks produced page after page of mostly s's. Not a single word emerged. Not even a two letter word. Not even a one letter word. Researcher Mike Phillips gave details.
At first, he said, “the lead male got a stone and started bashing the hell out of it.
“Another thing they were interested in was in defecating and urinating all over the keyboard,” added Phillips, who runs the university's Institute of Digital Arts and Technologies.
They didn't write any Shakespeare! They shit all over the computer!
Alright, alright, so it wasn't a real science experiment. It was more pop art. And they didn't have an infinite number of monkey or computers (due to budgetary constraints). Surely, if you had a infinite number, groused the guardians of evolution, then you would end up with Shakespeare.
Hmmmm. Well, maybe. But wouldn't you also need an infinite number of shovels to dig through an infinite pile of you know what?
University and zoo personnel defended their monkeys. Clearly, they didn't want them held responsible for sabotaging science. Geoff Cox, from the university, pointed out that "the monkeys aren't reducible to a random process. They get bored and they shit on the keyboard rather than type." And Vicky Melfi, a biologist at Paignton zoo, added "they are very intentional, deliberate and very dexterous, so they do want to interact with stuff you give them," she said. "They would sit on the computer and some of the younger ones would press the keys." Ultimately the monkeys may have fallen victim to the distractions which plague many budding novelists.
It's true. I often get distracted working on my book and when that happens I will sometimes shi......no, no.....some secrets are too dark to reveal!
****** The bookstore
I think the monkeys are smarter than we are giving them credit for. Let's face it, computers aren't very interesting in and of themselves.
If I sat you in front of a computer and asked you to randomly hit keys for months and months and months, how long before you start thinking of how to express your opinion of your "job."
I think the monkeys were making a statement about office work. As far as the hammer goes: Windows Vista...
Posted by: Screech | June 22, 2007 at 12:30 PM
Check out this post on my blog - Michael Behe is releasing a new book. http://vigilo-et-spero.blogspot.com/2007/06/behes-new-book.html
Posted by: Apologian | June 25, 2007 at 11:48 PM
http://vigilo-et-spero.blogspot.com/2007/06/behes-new-book.html
Behe's new book.
Posted by: Apologian | June 25, 2007 at 11:50 PM