Bailing, Bailing, and Bailing
Felix, Festus, Agrippa, and Paul

Wealth Distribution and the Jubilee

I plucked the latest Economist from my mailbox and thought I’d picked up the Watchtower by mistake. “World on the Edge” read the headline. Sure enough, on the cover was a silhouetted figure peering fearfully over the edge into the chasm below. And the edge was crumbling. Such illustrations have become commonplace in these recent days of financial meltdown.

A week or two ago, news anchor Suzie Gherow asked her economist guest (alas, I forgot his name) if he could come up with a moral to the unfolding crisis. He observed that many peoples worldwide look to the American economic system as a model to admire and emulate. He wondered if they would still do that "when they see how badly we’ve behaved.” As if responding to cue, Vladimir Putin, of all people, recently accused: “Everything happening now in the economic and financial sphere began in the United States. This is not the irresponsibility of specific individuals but the irresponsibility of the system that claims leadership.” I read this in an on-line newspaper. It included comments. Most bloggers agreed with Putin.

At any rate, government leaders are scrambling to come up with innovative solutions, doing things that not long ago would have been unthinkable…..countries assuming their banks’ bad debts, even nationalizing the banks….a partial nationalization here in the U.S, which is close to heresy in the land of free enterprise. One almost thinks of those verses that tell how mountains and hills during the “last days” would melt. The very institutions that seem to us as solid and unshakable as the literal mountains seemed to ancient peoples, are indeed shaking quickly.

In such a climate, it becomes crucial to assign blame. With that in mind, the appropriate committee of Congress (the House Committee on Government Reform) recently grilled Lehman Brothers ex-CEO Dick Fuld. For the most part Mr. Fuld outmaneuvered them. There’s a lot of Congressmen on that committee, and they all had to have their crack at him, so they weren’t allotted too much time apiece. Mr. Fuld succeeded in running out the clock…..repeating questions aloud, questioning premises, answering slowly and deliberately. Plus, there were not a few windbags among those politicians who wasted much of their time formulating their questions….you know, with prefaces and addendums and things, the way politicians like to do. Too, the Reprentatives were so wrapped up in their own questions that they didn't listen to answers of other people's questions. Thus, there was much repetition.

While Mr. Fuld was being interviewed, CNBC reported that a sore Lehman employee had socked him in the kisser some days ago while he was working out at the company gym!….a move he apparently did not outmaneuver.

Depending upon who you listen to, Mr. Fuld conveyed genuine remorse for Lehman’s demise. On the matter of compensation, however, he didn’t budge an inch. Though he made tens of millions of dollars in the very year his company tanked, that was proper remuneration, he insisted. After all, he pointed out, had the company remained solvent, he would have made much more. But this didn’t sit too well with the general public. If I had a dollar for every gripe I’ve heard about “obscene profits” of the big bankers, I, too, would have obscene profits and people could gripe about me.

When the new system at last arrives…..the government from God that the Bible speaks of and that Jehovah’s Witnesses advertise……will there be “obscene profits” in the hands of a very few? If the economic system handed down to ancient Israel is any guide, the answer is no. The Jubilee provision would see to that.

Every 50th year of that ancient agrarian system was the Jubilee year. At that time, each Jew was restored to his or her original allotted land inheritance. Through an interplay of hard work and dumb luck some would have prospered in those 50 years, others would have declined, maybe to the point of becoming impoverished. Land might well have been bought or sold. But not in perpetuity. On that 50th year, all things were set as at the beginning. Thus, while one would be rewarded for one’s work and business acumen, there would never take root a permanent underclass, nor a permanent wealthy class…..a situation characteristic of most societies today.

Some aspects of the cycle repeated every 7th year. Due to debts incurred, a Jew might even sell himself into slavery to one of his more prosperous neighbors. Laws regulated against mistreatment; moreover after seven years at most, the individual was set free, and that with a gift (from the prior owner) to assist him in starting anew. Again, neither a perpetual privileged class nor a locked-in poverty class could ever take root under that God-given arrangement.  Even were a man to squander every opportunity he had, the law was such that his children would still live to see equilibrium restored.

Awhile back I ran a post entitled Slavery in the Old Testament, intending to counter those critics who rail against the Bible for acknowledging and regulating slavery, rather than forbidding it. The post clarified the nature of OT slavery and, to my surprise, some commented that such slavery sounded pretty good compared to the plight of the homeless today, or even the working poor. Screecheven broke it down into figures which I will reproduce, confident he won’t mind:

“In the US minimum wage is currently $5.85 an hour. Lets suppose that you work 2 jobs; one FT and one PT. So 12 hours at that pay is $70.20 before taxes. After taxes are withheld, you have $56.87 a day left. You spend $65 (you have a cheap one) at your doctor's office. You get lucky and only spend $4 on the antibiotics that you need. You also are forced to take 3 days off from both jobs while you recover. Total cost is $239.58. That's four and a half days of pay. So if you have rent of $650 monthly, $135 monthly utilities (phone, electricity), $100 monthly food, $50 transportation costs. Now, in the above scenario, you have $200 left over every month. However, if you lose one of your jobs, suddenly you're short almost $200 monthly. What if you have a kid? 2 Jobs may not be an option and then you have to pay for daycare. Then you hear "go back to school." Yet if you have to take remedial classes to catch up, that adds to the expense (grants alone rarely cover everything). I guess the whole point of this rambling is that to overcome poverty in this world takes an astounding amount of sacrifice and will, with no guarantee of success. In fact, you also don't get real medical attention because the medical bills can pile up. I've seen and experienced the difference in medical care that you receive when you can afford to pay the bill vs not. It's actually a worse situation today…”

About a third of all those in Congress are millionaires, with a higher proportion in the Senate. Less than 1% of the general population fall into that category. It doesn’t give confidence that one might get justice from these guys, does it?….how many of them can even imagine how ordinary people live? Yet their wealth is dwarfed by that of the high-profile bankers who have lately been testifying before them….guys like Dick Fuld. A little Jubilee might work wonders today.

Of course, it could never be superimposed upon today’s society, just as Jesus said: one can’t pour new wine into old wineskins. The prevailing system wouldn’t accommodate it, few folks today have dispostions that would tolerate it. But those trained in Bible principles today should be amenable to it or whatever economic system God provides in the new order. There’s no telling to what degree, if any, God’s new system will draw from that ancient Jubilee arrangement. Nonetheless, the arrangement does offer a glimpse into Jehovah’s thinking.


Tom Irregardless and Me     No Fake News but Plenty of Hogwash

Defending Jehovah’s Witnesses with style from attacks... in Russia, with the book ‘I Don’t Know Why We Persecute Jehovah’s Witnesses—Searching for the Why’ (free).... and in the West, with the book, 'In the Last of the Last Days: Faith in the Age of Dysfunction'



Wow! Thanks for the quote. It's true that trying to change this world would be like pouring new wine into an old wineskin. You'd get a big mess.

One thing to keep in mind about this bailout...all it is designed to do is take the risk of a depression off of the table. So, depending on your accounting style, the US has spent and is authorized to spend about $2 trillion total to simply keep things from getting too bad.

It's ok, though (insert sarcasm here), because even though we are going to inflate our currency to keep pace, the rest of the world will have to inflate theirs more so we'll still look good...

In other words, I know I'm wiping pooh all over myself, but the other guys in the park are wiping more pooh on themselves! So you wanna go to dinner?

Interesting, huh?

Awake In Rochester

They say that America is the richest country. If that's true, then I think that we should have had something to start with as a base line. Like a house, or free education. I don't think that any Americans should be so poor that they go to bed hunger, or live in a tent. I saw on national news that tent cities are starting to spring up. Not as bad as depression days, but still.

I've heard that bankruptcy was based on the Jubilee 7th year cycle. All debts were suppose to be forgiven. But people don't even have that now. Congress has given people much more paperwork which discourages them from going bankrupted, plus not all debts are forgiven.

tom sheepandgoats


I hadn't heard about the tent cities. But maybe I'll be hearing more shortly.


Considering what I read in Isaiah and Micah, I think we can look forward to something better than the systems we all live under now.

It seems to me that Jehovah's original arrangement was that each man would have his own land and his own home and since the earth at that time will be perfected and produce more than it does now, none of us will have to worry about falling into abject poverty. We'll be able to produce our own furniture, clothing, pottery, jewelry, all of the things that people once crafted before the industrialized throw-away society was created. We'll have a measure of economic independence that none of us have today.

I see proof enough of that wonderful future in the talents and abilities of the brothers and sisters when it comes to quick builds, how Bethel facilities are run and some of the creative things that I see brothers and sisters do on a smaller scale every day.


I imagine the time on the earth at least after the thousand year reign is going to be pretty much similar as to how the Israelites lived their lives during the time of the judges:

(Judges 21:25) . . .In those days there was no king in Israel. What was right in his own eyes was what each one was accustomed to do.

Obviously they had the law, so they did what was right according to their understanding of the law. No unnecessary bureaucracy, red tape, unnecessary laws that just burden the people and take their freedom away, no people setting themselves up over them to oppress them. Jehovah was the king, and he gave them a few hundred laws, that all boiled down to love Jehovah your God with all your heart, soul, strength, and love your neighbor as yourself. The Israelites had it made. Why they wanted to elect a human king over them is beyond me. They often made stupid decisions.

Can you imagine the freedom? Sure, they lived under the law covenant, but that protected them, and actually made their freedom more enjoyable.

Jehovah is a God of freedom. Eventually all his creation will be free to live the way they want too, with Jehovah as the only head over all, again, after Jesus hands the kingdom back to his Father, as he rid us of the "last enemy death":

(James 1:25) . . .But he who peers into the perfect law that belongs to FREEDOM and who persists in [it], this [man], because he has become, not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, will be happy in his doing [it].

Ed Hughes

Tom Sheep and Goats,

Wealth Distribution and the Jubilee; what a wonderful system that would be today for everyone, God would provide land and a house and if you lost that by any manner you just waited for the Jubilee and it was yours again in less than 50 years. The individual did not have to work to get his property back, but he could sign himself up on the indebted servant plan and be restored to his previous status at the end of 7 years (and not be mistreated in any way during those 7 years). What was supposed to happen to the individual if he chose to wait out the 50 year period rather than being an indebted servant? Welfare, or just head for the desert where a benevolent God would provide manna from heaven again?

The sentence above describes just about what would happen in the debacle of today. Our United States, if things go as the system that tried to give everyone the American dream without proving themselves continues, each foreclosed mortgage owner will probably receive manna from heaven in the form of a re-contracted loan guaranteed by the taxpayers of the United States. There seems to be something seriously wrong with a system that has allowed a small percentage of individuals to break the back of our financial system and destroy a goodly number of hard working individuals who have worked and saved almost as the system required.

I am not one of the anointed ones and this blog almost requires that a person quote a scripture or two. Not knowing much scripture I will have to borrow one from, Victrix, with the hope that he will approve, because it sounds as I believe.
(James 1:25) . . .But he who peers into the perfect law that belongs to FREEDOM and who persists in [it], this [man], because he has become, not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, will be happy in his doing [it]. Victrix


The comments to this entry are closed.